Tuesday, June 23, 2009

World Bank Publication: Justice vs. Peace

Many development practitioners, especially those from the West, promote Rule of Law as an intrinsic human value in itself, one that should be upheld and promoted as a basic right. However, given the often painful realities, some have argued that the official notice of justice should be dependent on peace, rather than necessarily the other way around. In Justice Versus Peace in Northern Kenya, a World Bank publication in its Justice and Development Working Paper Series, Tanja Chopra examines the often conflicting relationship between justice and peace. Tanja was formerly the program coordinator of the World Bank‟s Justice for the Poor Program in Kenya.

The conflicting relationship between peace and justice is frequently debated in the field of transitional justice. The obligation to prosecute serious crimes can contradict the measures necessary to reestablish peace among society. The predicament gives rise to a similar, though less obvious, challenge in many developing countries, where the formal justice system can be at odds with conflict management initiatives. Often, due to their inaccessibility or incompatibility with local socio-cultural norms, official justice institutions in developing countries do not fully penetrate the whole of society. In response, conflict management and peacebuilding initiatives have proven to be more flexible and responsive to socio-political realities. While such initiatives may be more efficient in reestablishing the peace between communities in conflict, they may contradict the official law.

Current policy efforts and practices in the arid lands of Kenya illustrate this dilemma. Official justice institutions have proven too weak or ill-suited to prevent or resolve conflicts between local communities. To address the prevailing tensions, local ad hoc peace initiatives have developed, which operate on the basis of local norms and include local stakeholders. Given their relative success, some high level state agents have embraced the initiatives. The Office of the President is currently drafting a national policy framework on conflict management and peacebuilding, which is in part based on the experiences in the arid lands. Such a policy framework will ultimately have to deal with a similar dilemma known from the field of transitional justice: a decision between the establishment of peace and the application of formal justice may be required.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...